When it ended, it left a gap that nothing else seemed to fill. Joss Whedon's subsequent creations -- Firefly, Dollhouse, The Avengers -- do not explore the same territory. But other shows, books, and movies fill a lot of that need.
Here are some of my favorites -- TWENTY of them, in fact. Often inspired, frequently challenging, all of these novels, movies, and series are ones that I have loved in much the same way I loved BUFFY, and I believe you'll feel the same way.
The tv series VERONICA MARS is often mentioned as a recommendation for Buffy fans, but it's not just that it's a show about a blonde teenager; Veronica Mars is solid storytelling.
In some alternate universe, a universe without Buffy, Veronica Mars is far and away my favorite tv heroine. Not so much a fighter as a detective, Veronica is a teenage outsider on a quest to understand her world -- a world that won't make sense until she solves the murder of her best friend, Lilly. Using her intelligence and skills learned from her private investigator father, Veronica solves crimes in a film noir version of high school, in a town where class struggle and racial tension are always simmering.
That first season is as close as I have seen to television perfection. Sure, some mysteries-of-the-week are flimsy, but sharp dialogue, interesting characters, a father-daughter relationship for the ages, and the flawlessly unfolding mystery of who killed Lilly Kane make for simply staggering amounts of awesome.
The series declined, season by season. If the latter two seasons had been even close to the quality of the first, VM would likely have eclipsed Buffy for me. And that's saying something.
WHY BUFFY FANS WILL LIKE IT
Veronica Mars is a strong female protagonist with a sassy sense of humor. The TV show blends genres, builds suspense, and has more-than-adequate emotional payoffs.
WHAT ELSE IT OFFERS
This show is not afraid to explore the challenges of racial struggle and class differences. Its noir-style, hard-boiled mysteries never stop turning up the corruption and conspiracy, and struggling to solve the mysteries and uproot the injustice we have a protagonist with the resourcefulness to come out on top, the sense of humor to keep you chuckling, and the heart to break yours.
WHAT JOSS WHEDON SAID ABOUT IT
Joss called Veronica Mars the "Best. Show. Ever. Seriously, I've never gotten more wrapped up in a show I wasn't making, and maybe even more than those [...] These guys know what they're doing on a level that intimidates me. It's the Harry Potter of shows."
THE DRESDEN FILES
NOT the tv show, but the books.
For Buffy fans, probably the easiest way to understand the basic setup is, what if Xander were a wizard/private eye, saving the world from vampires, Faerie Queens, demons, ghosts, and other wizards? Imagine the kind-hearted goofball as protagonist, and you'll have a little sense of who Harry Dresden is.
Then add in an endearing cast of characters, clever mysteries, terrifying monsters, a hero who's totally not in the same weight-class as his enemies but manages to engage in desperate acts of badassery, and you might have a sense of Just. How. Good. this series is.
The first couple of books are fast, enjoyable reads, but about four or five books in, something just clicks, and there's no going back. One moment you'll be tense, and a moment later you'll be pumping your fist in the air at an astonishing act of whup-ass. You'll find yourself staying up all night to finish the riveting story, and then you'll be startled at how quickly you've burned through all fourteen goddamned books and now you're ready to gnaw at your fists because you just can't wait for the next installment of superfun.
WHY BUFFY FANS WILL LIKE IT
THE DRESDEN FILES is written in a first-person voice ("I crossed the street" instead of "he walked across the street"), and Harry Dresden's running commentary is often laugh-out-loud funny, with the same kind of sharp humor, pop-culture and geek-culture references, and wordplay we loved in BtVS. And that's not all.
Remember how you came to love not just Buffy, but Xander, Willow, and Giles? And Angel, Spike, Oz, and Tara? THE DRESDEN FILES has a cast of characters like that. They become people you care about and welcome into your home. I don't want to give spoilers, so I won't talk about who the characters are, but I will say that I've come to cherish some of them in just the same way I adored seeing Willow, Xander, and Giles on my tv screen.
And yes, there's also a ton of fun action, and a really enjoyable supernatural universe, but it's the characters here, as in Buffy, who keep people tuning in.
SHAUN OF THE DEAD
I'm not ordinarily a fan of zombie movies, but what do you say about a film whose opening credits show a horde of walking corpses shambling along mindlessly, and presents them as indistinguishable from morning commuters on their way to work, before they've had their second cup of coffee? This is a scene that contains more wit and insight than half a dozen Hollywood flicks rolled together -- and that's just the opening credits.
Shaun works retail, which makes him an unlikely hero. But when the zombie apocalypse arrives, everyone has choices to make, and Shaun's not the kind of guy who'll let his friends, his mom, or his ex-girlfriend get their brains eaten by any old horde of the undead. This is a movie with horror and desperation, but it's also a movie with wit, featuring a character with tenacity and heart. I love this flick.
Why Buffy fans will like it
BtVS reinvented the vampire movie and the slasher flick. It took the tropes of the predator and the defenseless nubile teenage girl and asked the question, what if the stereotypical victim could kick ass? SHAUN OF THE DEAD does the same with the zombie movie. The dead keep coming, and our unlikely hero has to find the inner strength and the resourcefulness to not only survive, but to protect the people he cares about.
Using the conventions of a film genre to tell a challenging story? Check.
Unlikely hero? Check.
Reluctant hero? Check.
Wit? Hell yeah check.
Likeable characters? Check.
Profound, terrifying, moving, important art? Check.
WHAT JOSS WHEDON SAID ABOUT IT:
SHAUN OF THE DEAD is "the movie that made me absolutely the most gleeful in the last year. ... That’s the kind of movie that makes me want to make movies. ... I met Simon Pegg backstage at a convention, we were about to go on, and I didn’t know who he was or what was going on, and I said 'Hey. Hi… I don’t where we’re meeting.' .... And then I saw the movie and I was like, 'Oh, you’re way cooler than me.'"
Joss Whedon's FRAY
Yes, it's a comic book.
"But," you say.
"Ug," you say.
"Er," you say.
"I don't read comic books," you say.
"Get over it," I say.
Joss Whedon wrote FRAY. And it's about a Slayer, in the distant future.
Yes, my friends, it's part of the canonical literature of BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER. And, in my opinion, it's better than anything else Joss Whedon has done that wasn't named Buffy. I like Firefly, Angel, Dollhouse, and the Avengers, but I like FRAY better.
Joss has written other comics, like ASTONISHING X-MEN, SUGAR SHOCK, and THE RUNAWAYS, and for you, my friends, I've read them. I've read them all. But FRAY is different. FRAY might be Whedon's most perfect creation. For FRAY, Joss Whedon took the mythology underlying BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER, brought it into a dystopian future, and created a whole new cast of characters. These characters -- allies and enemies -- are beautifully balanced to create fascinating conflict and generate fresh stories.
Again, I don't want to give spoilers here. In a dystopian future, Melaka Fray is a Slayer who makes her living as a petty thief in the squalid slums of Haddyn. But for some reason, Mel only received some of the gifts of the Slayer line -- she has the strength and speed, but not the dreams, and not the knowledge. The Watchers' Council has fallen into disarray, and the forces of darkness are rising once again. To understand her power, Mel may have to seek the guidance of demons -- but her opponents may be more than she expects.
FRAY is a carefully crafted storyline from start to finish, with some of those unexpected turns that will have you shouting "DAMN YOU JOSS WHEDON!" Fray was only an eight-issue limited series, but it was tight, rewarding, and emotional in all the right ways. It's a crime that nobody has bought the film rights.
This is a series of novels by a husband-wife team who write under the pseudonym Ilona Andrews. Kate Daniels is the heroine of this fascinating series set in a future where magic has been returning. Now magic and technology work in alternating waves; for a few days magic will work and technology won't, and then for a few days technology will work and magic won't. Society has been crumbling under the pressures of this bizarre occurrence.
And mythical beasts have been making their presence known. There are shapeshifters, who live by complex social dynamics, and there are vampires, which are unlike any vampires you've seen before. The vampires in this world are strong, fast, and mindless, "piloted" by telepathic riders known only as the People. The People have mysterious goals of their own.
But that's okay, because our heroine, Kate Daniels, has mysteries of her own, too. She has powers she keeps hidden, even in this madcap world. She fights with a sword called Slayer, which gives off smoke when she's angry. She's a badass who can stand her own in a world of badasses, and the series will see her grow from an outsider suspicious of everyone into a confident woman who has made a place for herself and developed trusted allies.
The cast of characters here is just wonderful. You'll find minor characters like a medic who's a were-badger, and his love for honey drives him to serve sickeningly sweet iced tea. There's romance here without being needy or obtrusive, and then there's a villain -- the immortal Roland -- casting a long shadow over the entire series.
Transnational Geek's Strong Recommendations are movies and tv shows that rank just below the Top Recommendations. In some cases, they're amazing works that differ too substantially from Buffy to be a clear recommendation to Buffy fans, and in other cases they're works that share similarities with Buffy but maybe lack a little inspiration.
TODD AND THE BOOK OF PURE EVIL
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? Well, some people won't get past its juvenility. If you can, you'll love it.
Patricia Briggs’ MERCY THOMPSON is one of the most vivid, enduring figures in contemporary urban fantasy fiction. In this series, she shapeshifts into a coyote, while those around her tend to be vampires and werewolves – physically much stronger. For her to establish her place and defend her boundaries, it takes social intelligence and carefully applied uses of her limited power. She contends with werewolf pack dynamics, vampire society, and faerie clans. And she’s an auto mechanic specializing in high-end cars. This series is brilliant, witty, and frequently insightful.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? There are elements of extreme victimization in the series, which make it less empowering than The Buffster.
DOCTOR WHO (2005)
Showrunner Russell T. Davies launched this reinvented sci-fi series in 2005. Davies has said in interviews that BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER was one of his inspirations for the show. DOCTOR WHO clearly shares some of BUFFY's strengths: it has a kinetic style of direction, energetic storytelling and a pervasive sense of fun with occasional touches of tragedy. Some truly memorable images, such as the Vashta Narada, the Weeping Angels, and the Silence.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? DOCTOR WHO is fun, and sometimes heartwrenching, but it's just not as deep as BUFFY. Still, if you're looking for an energetic show with some feeling of BUFFY-ness to it, and you don't mind the fundamental fluffy-ness, you'll enjoy DOCTOR WHO.
CROUCHING TIGER, HIDDEN DRAGON
Ang Lee's award-winning CROUCHING TIGER, HIDDEN DRAGON explores gender, power, and culture by telling the story of a young swordswoman who steals a famous sword belonging to a master swordsman. With breathtaking cinematography, beautiful scenery, dreamlike, balletic kung fu, and some thrilling action scenes, Crouching Tiger is a complex, deep, and thought-provoking tale.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? It's a great movie, but it has a completely different feel from Buffy. There is no pop culture, no laugh-out-loud humor, and no monsters. However, there is profundity, feminism, beauty, and tragedy.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? The movie was made on an extremely low budget, and many of its effects appear campy. It doesn't have the tragic depth of BUFFY, but still, if you're looking for a thrilling, fun, funny movie, MR. VAMPIRE may hit the spot.
GINGER SNAPS is a coming-of-age film where a teenage girl becomes a werewolf, and her lycanthropy is a metaphor for girls undergoing puberty: their bodies change in ways they may not understand, and the lunar cycle becomes a force in their lives. It's got witty dialogue, a pair of clever outsider sisters, some cool werewolf-driven horror, and some actual emotional depth.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? I'm... not sure? I've only seen it once, and I don't feel comfortable giving it a top recommendation based on a single viewing.
TALES OF THE VAMPIRES framing story
There's a graphic novel called TALES OF THE VAMPIRES, with short comics by a number of different authors. But there's a framing story around the rest; Joss Whedon wrote it, and it's great. A little girl in the 19th Century is being trained to become a Watcher, but things are not what they seem in this superb little gem of a story that ties into the lives of our Scooby Gang.
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? Well, it's not available by itself. To read the story, you have to flip through a lot of mediocre stories.
Quentin Tarantino's KILL BILL might be lacking a little depth, but boy does it make up for it in sizzle. Influenced by Shaw Brothers swordplay flicks, Blaxploitation movies, and Japanese "pinky violence" sleaze, Tarantino crafted a flashy, colorful tribute to some of the most energetic cinema in the world. A female assassin seeks revenge on the leader of a team of female assassins, and she'll kill anyone who gets in her way. Like a roller-coaster of beautifully choreographed scenes, some serene, some violent, KILL BILL slashes its way into funtown.
VAMPIRELLA VS. FLUFFY
Why isn't it one of TRANSNATIONAL GEEK's TOP RECOMMENDATIONS? Somehow I didn't get a sense that the movie really took the issues of teen pregnancy seriously. It all feels too easy.
These books, movies, and tv shows all have something really good going on, but they all also have reasons I hesitate to recommend them.
THE VAMPIRE DIARIES
THE HUNGER GAMES
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE CLASSIC
#10: RING OF FIRE, was written by Doug Petrie, a writer of the tv show. Petrie wrote the season 5 episode, Fool For Love, where Spike's back-story is explored. RING OF FIRE was originally supposed to be an episode in BUFFY's second season, where Angel is a bad guy, but it had to be cut due to the special effects budget.
These comics are not brilliant storytelling, but they really do have something to offer to the devoted Buffy fan.
And this concludes our presentation. I hope you enjoyed it, and if you think there's something I'm missing, please let me know in the comments!